Date: Sun, 22 Jul 2001 15:15:06 +0000
From: shafik@shafik.net
To: jcristof@adobe.com, dstyerwa@adobe.com, lvacante@adobe.com, ablatchf@adobe.com, skrueger@adobe.com, gbabbit@adobe.com, wsaso@adobe.com, jwarnock@adobe.com, cgeschke@adobe.com, bchizen@adobe.com, snarayen@adobe.com, mdemo@adobe.com, gfreeman@adobe.com, cpouliot@adobe.com, jstephens@adobe.com, mdyrdahl@adobe.com, lepstein@adobe.com, lsellers@adobe.com, blamkin@adobe.com

Subject: Concerns from a potential customer

After reading the coverage about the arrest of Dmitry Sklyarov from www.theregister.co.uk, www.eff.org and eventually www.boycottadobe.com. I feel I have gathered enough facts to condemn your company for such a awful abuse of my Constitutionally protected rights.

The DMCA is a misconceived law, that attempts to take away every Americans right to fair use and in my opinion to protect companies that do not want to bother with real security but give their customers symbolic security which does no one any good and is the key reason why the Internet was plagued by the CodeRed worm this week.

I have been considering for a while if I should bother trying out Photoshop after playing with "The Gimp" www.gimp.org, but at this point I doubt I will be purchasing any Adobe products ever and I will be encouraging everyone I know to avoid Adobe products.

I will also be doing my best to show people in other companies as well as mine how powerful "The Gimp" is and how they can replace Photoshop with it. I am not that familiar with all your products but I will be on the lookout for products that can replace products that you produce and educating people that free alternatives exist.

As a company you should be ashamed for at least two reasons, 1 that you could not create a security mechanism that was nothing more then basic and 2 that you are contributing to the erosion of basic American rights and protections. Maybe you should all take some time and read :

The Constitution
"The Federalist Papers"
Tocqueville's "Democracy in America"
F.A. Hayek's "The Road to Serfdom"
Bruce Schneier's "The Futility of Digital Copy Protection" http://www.counterpane.com/crypto-gram-0105.html#3

For your security team I might advise the following reading:
Bruce Schneier's "Applied Cryptography"
AND
http://www.counterpane.com/crypto-gram.html

Your truely
Shafik Yaghmour

 

back